Tequila!
November 15, 2026
In Casa Tradición S.A. de C.V. v. Casa Azul Spirits, L.L.C., the Fifth Circuit vacated a bench-trial judgment that the “Casa Azul” mark, for canned tequila sodas and bottled tequila, was not likely to be confused with the “Clase Azul” mark for luxury tequila. Specifically, the Court held that the district court’s “no likelihood of confusion” conclusion rested on erroneous findings on four of the eight digits of confusion.
First, on strength of the mark, the district court clearly erred in calling Clase Azul descriptive. The mark is suggestive, because a consumer must first infer that “azul” refers to blue weber agave, and, as the court put it, “[t]he Kelley Blue Book is not a catalog of tequila”. The district court also clearly erred in finding that the mark lacked strong standing in the marketplace. And it committed legal error by measuring third-party use of “casa” and “azul” rather than “clase” and “azul,” which are the terms the senior mark actually contains.
Second, the products are similar as a matter of law. Both parties sell bottled, distilled tequila at 40% alcohol, which “alone is more than sufficient,” and the price gap is not wide enough to make a common source implausible. The canned sodas are also related, because consumers could reasonably believe a tequila brand had expanded into ready-to-drink cocktails, as Jack Daniel’s, Crown Royal, and others have.
Third, the district court’s finding that Clase Azul is not sold in grocery or big-box stores was clearly erroneous, so its findings on retail outlets and consumers have to be reconsidered.
Fourth, the district court overlooked substantial anecdotal evidence of actual confusion. That evidence included a distributor employee who thought Casa Azul was a “new line extension” of Clase Azul, a bar owner who asked whether it was a new Clase Azul product, and a Total Wine review that criticized a Clase Azul tequila but showed a photo of Casa Azul. The panel held that these instances “are not isolated incidents” but “reveal real confusion in the market—both by consumers and by distributors who know this market well.” It also held that the actual-confusion digit “must cut in favor of a likelihood of confusion,” while leaving its weight to the district court.
The panel did not disagree with the district court’s findings on similarity of the marks, advertising, and purchaser care, and remanded for reassessment. A dissent argued that the majority misapplied clear-error review. No. 24-20255 (Nov. 4, 2026).