PREP not completely PRE-emptive.

March 23, 2022

The PREP Act — a 2005 law allowing the HHS secretary to make a declaration that immunizes certain disaster responders from liability — was held not to completely preempt state-law negligence claims in Mitchell v. Advanced HCS. The Fifth Circuit noted:

  • First, the only cause of action [the PREP Act] creates is for willful misconduct. Assuming—without deciding—that the willful misconduct cause of action is completely preemptive, the question is whether Mitchell ‘could have brought’ the instant claims under that cause of action. He could not. The Act clearly states that its willful-misconduct cause of action creates ‘a standard for liability that is more stringent than a standard of negligence in any form or recklessness.'”
  • Second, the compensation fund that the Act creates is not completely preemptive under this court’s precedents. To begin, a ‘compensation fund is not a cause of action.’ It may be a civil-enforcement provision, but such provisions must nevertheless ‘create[] a cause of action.’ … Assuming arguendo that the compensation fund suffices as a cause of action, the Act nevertheless does not create ‘a specific jurisdictional grant to the federal courts for enforcement of the right.’ Instead, the Secretary oversees administration of the fund. Worse, the statute expressly withdraws jurisdiction from any court, state or federal, concerning ‘any action [taken] by the Secretary’ in doing so.”

No. 21-10477 (March 10, 2022) (citations omitted, emphasis added).

Follow by Email
Twitter
Follow Me