Book Sales and the First Amendment

In Book People, Inc. v. Wong, the Fifth Circuit reviewed the constitutionality of the Texas “READER” law, which “requires school book vendors who want to do business with Texas public schools to issue sexual-content ratings for all library materials they have ever sold (or will sell), flagging any materials deemed to be ‘sexually explicit’ or ‘sexually relevant’ based on the materials’ depictions of or references to sex.”

The Court held that the law violated the First Amendment, in that the ratings required by the law were not government speech, and fell within no exception to the rule against “compelled speech”:

1.  They did not come within the “government operations” exception because they “go[] beyond a mere disclosure of demographic or similar factual information.”
2. Similarly, they were not a permissible commercial-speech regulation because “[b]alancing a myriad of factors that depend on community standards is anything but the mere disclosure of factual information.

No. 23-50668 (Jan. 17, 2024).