When Your Argument Isn’t Working — UPDATED

You can tell your argument isn’t working when the Fifth Circuit summarizes it as follows:

“SCW’s last remaining counterargument is that it should be able to pick and choose different clauses from the LSAA and the Grant Agreement and then mush them together to demand money from debtors.”

and when the Court begins its opinion:

“Widowed octogenarians Iris Calogero and Margie Nell Randolph received dunning letters from a Louisiana law firm … .”

Calogero v. Shows, Cali & Walsh, LLP,  No. 22-30487 (March 15, 2024). More substantive review to follow in the week ahead!