Noerr-Pennington Doctrine Steel Viable
March 24, 2025In JSW Steel (USA) Inc. v. Nucor Corp., the Fifth Circuit affirmed the dismissal of JSW Steel’s antitrust claims against Nucor, U.S. Steel, and AK Steel.
The Court held that JSW failed to plausibly allege a conspiracy in violation of the Sherman Act. The allegations of parallel conduct by the defendants, such as their simultaneous objections to JSW’s tariff exclusion requests and their similar creditworthiness requirements, did not sufficiently suggest a preceding agreement. The Court emphasized that “parallel conduct that could just as well be independent action” does not meet the threshold for establishing a conspiracy under the Sherman Act.
Additionally, the Court found that much of the conduct alleged by JSW was protected under the Noerr-Pennington doctrine, which shields parties from antitrust liability when petitioning the government for favorable action. That activity included the defendants’ certifications to the Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) and their coordination in discussing changes to the steel Section 232 exclusion process. No. 22-20149, Mar. 17, 2025