Named Insured means Named Insured.
October 14, 2014Holden, an employee of Buck Kreihs Company (“BKS”), was injured while removing a gangway that connected BKS’s dock to a barge owned by U.S. United Ocean Services (“United”). Holden and United settled their litigation, and United’s liability insurer won summary judgment in United’s suit for insurance coverage. The Fifth Circuit affirmed in Holden v. U.S. United Ocean Services, L.L.C., No. 12-30251 (Sept. 15, 2014, unpublished). The policy — actually issed to BKS, but with United as an additional insured — had a “watercraft” exclusion. The exclusion would otherwise apply to the barge, except for an exemption for a contract under which “the ‘Named Insured’ assumes the tort liability of another party for ‘bodily injury’ or ‘property damage’ to a third party or organization.” The majority found that United was not a named insured, and that the exemption was best read to reach claims by an injured claimant against BKS — not claims by an additional insured for its own liability to the claimant. A dissent argued that this reading did not give effect to the precise terms used in the policy.