More Legislative Privilege

It was a busy week for legislative privilege; after an opinion involving the latest dispute about the Jackson airport, the Fifth Circuit again ruled in favor of legislative-privilege claims in LULAC v. Hughes. The Court held that such matters were appropriately raised by interlocutory appeal, and on the merits observed:

“The privilege log shows that the legislators did not send privileged documents to third parties outside the legislative process; instead they brought third parties into the process. That decision did not waive the privilege. The very fact that Plaintiffs need discovery to access these documents shows that they have not been shared publicly. On the other hand, if the legislators had shared the documents publicly, then they could not rely on the privilege to prevent Plaintiffs from introducing those documents as evidence. But here, where the documents have been shared with some third parties—but haven’t been shared publicly—the waiver argument fails.”

No. 22-50435 (May 17, 2023) (emphasis in original).