Mandamus Granted re Ken Paxton Deposition- UPDATED

The Fifth Circuit granted mandamus relief as to an effort to subpoena Texas AG Ken Paxton for a deposition in a case about potentially overzealous enforcement of now-constitutional antiabortion laws.

The panel majority concluded: (1) that the district court lacked subject matter jurisdiction and thus could not require his testimony, citing a recent Circuit case involving discovery and qualified immunity; (2) that the subpoena sought an inappropriate “apex” deposition; and (3) that plaintiffs overreached by opposing mandamus relief (because of a potential remedy by appeal), while also seeking to dismiss Paxton’s interlocutory appeal on immunity grounds (thus, extinguishing same).

A concurrence would have focused on the apex issue and not the broader dispute about jurisdiction, at least at this stage of the proceedings. In re Paxton, No. 22-50882 (Nov. 14, 2022) — REVISED, (Feb. 14, 2023).