Excess, and really excess

In Great Am. Ins. Co. v. Employers Mut. Cas. Co., both the Great American and Employers’ umbrella policies were “excess,” in that they both provided coverage for liability “in excess” of a “retained limit.” That said . . .

• the Employers’ policy defined “retained limit” as “the available limits of all ‘underlying insurance,'” a term that was, in turn, defined by two descriptions of primary coverage; while
• the Great American policy defined “retained limit” to include “the applicable limits of any other insurance providing coverage to the ‘Insured’ during the Policy Period.” (emphasis added).

Thus, “[b]ased on the plain terms of these policies, the Great American Umbrella Policy was the true excess policy after all other policies.” No. 20-11113 (Nov. 17, 2021).