Debt and the Founding

April 23, 2023

In review of a court-supervised sale of real property in a bankruptcy case, the Fifth Circuit provided a deft summary of how bankruptcy came to be an area of concern to the framers of the Constitution:

Federal bankruptcy provisions date to the Founding, embedded into our Constitution as a core tenet of the country’s economic vitality. And with good reason: “[d]ebt was an inescapable fact of life in early America . . . [that] cut across regional, class, and occupational lines,” and debtor’s prisons were antithetical to the new democratic ideal. So, in parallel with the industrialization and modernization of our markets, the Bankruptcy Code matured, its execution shifting to an independent court staffed by an array of able judges selected by merit and expert in the field, giving bankruptcy courts with their new status a crucial role in freeing the entrepreneurial energy indispensable to our nation’s economy.

SR Construction, Inc. v. Hall Palm Springs LLC, No. 21-11244 (April 17, 2023) (citations omitted).

Follow by Email
Twitter
Follow Me