Contract terms preclude unjust enrichment claim
August 1, 2012City of New Orleans v. BellSouth Telecommunications presented a long-simmering dispute, stretching back to an 1879 ordinance, about BellSouth’s use of public rights-of-way in New Orleans. Nos. 11-30607 and 11-31058 (July 31, 2012). The district court awarded $1.5 million in unjust enrichment related to BellSouth’s use after 2006. The Fifth Circuit reversed, finding that the parties’ complicated relationship gave BellSouth a “‘justification in . . . contract’ for any enrichment it may be enjoying . . . ,” which defeated an unjust enrichment claim under Louisiana law. Id. at 21, 25 (citing SMP Sales Management v. Fleet Credit Corp., 960 F.2d 557, 560 (5th Cir. 1992)).