Amount in Controversy Controversy

Louisiana Indep. Pharmacies Ass’n v. Express Scripts, Inc. “presents a novel issue concerning the amount in controversy requirement for diversity jurisdiction in cases brought by organizations on behalf of their members.” An association of Louisiana pharmacists sought a declaration about their appropriate Medicare reimbursement, and while the total value of all their claims exceeded $75,000, the Fifth Circuit concluded that the law required that “at least one pharmacy would have to allege that Express Scripts shortchanged it on the provider fee for over 750,000 Medicare Part D prescriptions.” Accordingly, it dismissed for lack of subject matter jurisdiction. No. 21-30331 (July 20, 2022).