Not a Local Controversy

In Cheapside Minerals, Ltd. v. Devon Energy Prod Co., L.P., the Fifth Circuit concluded that CAFA’s “local controversy” exception did not apply, and thus reversed a remand to state court in an oil-and-gas royalties dispute:

[T]he “principal injury” each Plaintiff sustained is obvious because there was only one type of injury: a financial harm resulting from Devon’s alleged underpayment of their royalties. While most Plaintiffs sustained that injury in Texas, others did not. Therefore, the principal injuries prong is not satisfied in this case, and Plaintiffs have failed to demonstrate that the local controversy exception applies.

No. 24-40026 (March 1, 2024).