Dismiss, if you dare.

February 11, 2019

The surprisingly-complex issue of voluntary dismissal, addressed  by Fed. R. Civ. P. 41(a), led to the novel question in Welsh v. Correct Care LLC of whether the lack of an answer to an amended complaint, when the original pleading had been answered, allowed an automatic dismissal without prejudice. The Fifth Circuit held that it did not, and further noted that before the district court could condition such a dismissal on it being with prejudice, it would have to give the plaintiff a choice, as “[a] plaintiff typically ‘has the option to refuse a Rule 41(a)(2) voluntary dismissal and to proceed with its case if the conditions imposed by the court are too onerous.'” No. 17-11522 (Feb. 7, 2019).

Follow by Email
Twitter
Follow Me